Neon screwdriver

From DIYWiki
Revision as of 23:47, 15 April 2008 by NT (talk | contribs) (linkify)
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Neon screwdrivers are used to test mains circuits to see if they're live. However they have significant problems, and the majority view on uk.d-i-y is they're best not used at all.


How they work

Mains power flows down the screw driving tip to the resistor and neon in the handle. When you touch the brass cap, mains power flows through you, completing the circuit and lighting the neon.

The currents involved are small enough not to feel, so the normal current level is not a safety concern.


The Problems

Direct shock

Water or condensation on the resistor can result in the tool passing higher current to the user, causing a shock, maybe a fall from a ladder, and the slight risk of fatality.

Certain tool faults such as resistor failure can cause the same problem.


False negative

No connection of the human to earth will result in dim lighting on a live wire, and this can go unseen in daylight. The result is shock from touching a live wire, and this is probably the most common failure mechanism.


False Positive

A user capacitively connected to a live supply will light a neon screwdriver touched to any non-live wire. It is quite easy to be capacitively coupled in this way without noticing. Holding an inspection light, standing on a cable, even leaning on a wall in some cases, and so on.


Legality

Because of the issues with these tools, they are illegal to use at a place of work.


Further discussion

uk.d-i-y thread


Alternatives

The best alternative is a multimeter. A reasonable quality meter will do far more than a neon screwdriver, and do so with more reliable results. Multimeters have their own safety issues, but they are less and much more under the control of the end user, so can be minimised with care.


See Also