Difference between revisions of "Sizing a hot water cylinder"

Domestic hot water cylinders start at around 80L, and many makers do a range of sizes up to 300L or more. The smaller sizes being adequate for properties that have a single shower/bathroom. Larger sizes become more appropriate for larger properties with more baths and showers to cater for. Specifying the "right" size is not an exact science, and this article helps lead you through the decision process.

Factors to consider

The size required will be influenced by a number of factors:

• Water storage temperature
• Recovery time
• Maximum likely "single use" demand.

Water temperature

The higher the water storage temperature, the more energy contained in the cylinder. A smaller cylinder full of water at 70°C will produce the same amount of water at final mix temperature as a larger cylinder using a lower storage temperature. However choice of storage temperature is not a case of higher always being better...

• Temperatures over 60°C will tend to accelerate deposition of limescale inside the cylinder in hard water areas.
• Higher temperatures represent a scalding risk (although modern installations should usually use thermostatic blending valves in accordance with the building regulations to protect users)
• Lower temperatures will result in higher boiler efficiency when reheating with modern condensing boilers.
• Higher temperatures will more effectively kill bacteria such as legionella

With modern boiler controls one may also opt to run a cylinder at around 60°C normally, with a once a week heating to a higher temperature to ensure sanitisation.

Recovery time

Recovery time is dictated by how quickly heat can be transferred into the water in the cylinder, and how soon after the temperature falls that recovery is started.

With a very fast recovery, cylinder size can be reduced and demand still met. (there is also a positive feed back effect here - smaller cylinders will also reheat faster than larger ones)

Electrically heated cylinder recovery time is limited by the power of the immersion heater(s) fitted. Larger cylinders may allow for three of them, with a combined output of 9kW however this is still short of the output available from even a modest boiler.

Indirect cylinders are fitted with a heating coil. This allows water from the boilers primary circuit to circulate through the water in the cylinder without mixing with it, but allowing heat to transfer. Older cylinders (usually the vented type) typically have a coil that can transfer heat at a maximum rate of around 5kW with a primary flow temperature of 85°C (the lower the flow temperature, the lower the transfer rate). Many modern cylinders, and in particular most unvented cylinders will have a "fast recovery" coil. This will often allow flow rates of over 20kW (boiler power permitting) for a significant proportion of the reheat time.

Fast recovery cylinders favour heating control systems that can divert the full output of the boiler to the cylinder (W Plan, and S Plan for example), rather than the Y Plan that suited slower recover cylinders by allowing boiler output to be shared with the central heating at the same time as the cylinder reheating.

If the boiler is triggered to reheat the cylinder soon enough, then its also possible that even an almost depleted cylinder will be able to supply water for a lower delivery rate use such as a shower on an indefinite basis - the water being heated "on the fly".

A system where the controls allow the cylinder to recover at any time of day, can also work well with a smaller cylinder than if reheating times are restricted to certain times of day (i.e. via a CH timer/programmer or immersion timeswitch)

Maximum Demand

We want to estimate the amount of hot water likely to be required in any given single use (i.e. without much time for recovery) and make sure the cylinder is large enough to hold this much.

A typically bath will require 120L or more. A shower may well be less (or indeed more, depending on how long the shower takes, and the water use rate of the shower in question). However that is "mixed" water - i.e. hot and cold water added together to get the desired temperature.

${\displaystyle V_{t}=V_{c}+V_{h}}$


You can work out the amount of hot water required if you know the total volume of mixed water needed. The calculation is based on the ratio of temperature differences between the final mixed temperature, the hot and cold water temperatures:

Where:

• ${\displaystyle V_{t}}$ is the Total Volume of water required
• ${\displaystyle V_{c}}$ is Volume of cold water
• ${\displaystyle V_{h}}$ is Volume of hot water

The actual volume ratios are calculated using:

${\displaystyle HotWaterRatio=T_{m}-T_{c}}$

${\displaystyle ColdWaterRatio=T_{h}-T_{m}}$


Where

• ${\displaystyle T_{m}}$ is final mixed water Temperature
• ${\displaystyle T_{c}}$ is the Temperature of the incoming cold water
• ${\displaystyle T_{h}}$ is the Temperature of your hot water from the cylinder

So say you need 150L for a large bath, and you want it at 45 degrees (${\displaystyle T_{m}}$), while the cold water is at 10 degrees (${\displaystyle T_{c}}$), and the hot water is at 60 (${\displaystyle T_{h}}$). That gives you a ratio of:

${\displaystyle HotWaterRatio=45-10=35}$

${\displaystyle ColdWaterRatio=60-45=15}$

So you need hot and cold water in the ratio of 35 parts hot to 15 parts cold.


So if you split 150L total into that ratio:

${\displaystyle V_{c}={150 \over 15+35}\times 15}$

${\displaystyle V_{c}=45L}$of cold water

${\displaystyle V_{h}={150 \over 15+35}\times 35}$

${\displaystyle V_{h}=105L}$of hot water



So that shows a cylinder of capacity of 105L or more (say 120L) is about adequate for a single bath fill without reheating.

If you needed say 200L of water at 45 degrees, then you would need to increase the temperature of the stored hot water, or increase the size of the cylinder.