Talk:Main Page/Discussion
This page is for discussion of the DIY Wiki main page, and the Wiki as a whole.
It also seems to be a favoured place for spammers advertising dodgy pharmaceuticals, fakereplica Rolexes and so on <sigh>
Previous discussions on this page have been Archived
Spam avoidance
In another attempt to avoid spam the Talk:Main Page is now a redirect to this page. With luck automatic spambots will simply append their wares to the redirect page. We shall see ... --John Stumbles 23:29, 15 August 2007 (BST)
spam snipped
Hmmm, well that lasted all of about 5 minutes :-(
Now changed Talk:Main Page back to a normal page with a link saying to go to this one.
--John Stumbles 01:51, 16 August 2007 (BST)
This seems to have resulted in spam going back to the main talk page. I've added some HTML code to set the font to white so added spam should at least be invisible. It works on my browser but maybe not others - ?
--John Stumbles 09:15, 16 August 2007 (BST)
I felt the protected page actually worked ok. We only had a couple of hits to other pages in about 48 hours rather than the many we normally get per day.
- Or twice in less than an hour, depending on your POV! ;-) --John Stumbles 17:44, 16 August 2007 (BST)
--John Rumm 12:25, 16 August 2007 (BST) (posting via a proxy because I have now aquired an auto IP ban for a day due to accidentally blocking myself and then unblocking!)
I'm a bit concerned. There arent many of us and we have a lot of pages to look after. I'm happy to come along and wipe one page clean, but to chase all round the site reading 20 contributions a day and revert them all, day after day, forget it. If someone else is prepared to do that then great, but I personally think the most valuable thing here is that all spam lands on the one same page, making it easy to control.
So lets keep the talk:main page unprotected, move anything useful off it and we can just come along and wipe it as and when. I just dont see any other approach being workable. If we block contributions to talk:main then we'll lose the battle very fast imho. NT 14:18, 17 August 2007 (BST)
'Fraid it might already be too late for that: we're getting spammed all over the shop now. However all may not be lost: wikipedia has a gadget that makes you authenticate any edits that introduce external links, which is what 99.9% of the spam we've had so far consists of. If we could get that running on this wiki we'd be laughing. --John Stumbles 19:01, 17 August 2007 (BST)
That sounds good. I know nowt about it though.
It might be too late, or possibly not, it depends. we'll soon know. NT 23:10, 17 August 2007 (BST)
Aliases
Anyone know how to add aliases or other search terms to articles? I have noted that some articles are very hard to search for unless you know the exact title of the article. It would be useful if one could provide some extra search terms that would also lead you to an article.
For example searching for "outdoor electrics" or "garden electrics" finds nothing, but it would be handy if these took you to the "taking electricity outside" article etc.
Perhaps some redirects would be useful, taking alternative article titles to the appropriate place.
--John Rumm 13:05, 4 September 2007 (BST)
That's what Wikipedia seems to do so I guess that's the only way. I've created a few when I've tried to find a page which I know exists but can't remember the exact name of (or CBA to type out :-)) --John Stumbles 17:39, 4 September 2007 (BST)
The other way is to add those keywords & keyphrases into the articles somewhere. There are a few articles that have lists of such keyphrases at the bottom.
NT 19:01, 4 September 2007 (BST)
Another option is how the Lighting page is done. As well as listing the key articles for each subtopic, it also contains (under 'more topics') a list of further topics that are covered within pages that dont bear the name of the topic. IOW its a directory page to lighting topics.
Even better may be to put such stuff on the lighting category page, so the page has 3 sections:
- list of all lighting articles
- list of key articles for each lighting area
- list of other secondary lighting topics covered within other articles
NT 19:09, 4 September 2007 (BST)
I just tried adding keywords to a couple of articles. On the outdoor electrics one it seemed to work quite well. Many search terms bring it up near the top of the hits. However I also tried it on the 2 way switching one, and that was less successful. Searching for "two way" still finds nothing. It may be that the actual words are getting dropped by the media wiki search as being minor words.
--John Rumm 19:21, 4 September 2007 (BST)
Fixed it. Altered one of the headings near the top from 2 way to two way, now it comes up as no 1 in searches.
NT 00:10, 5 September 2007 (BST)
Spam avoidance: CAPTCHA
I think I've found what I was looking for.
http://www.mediawiki.org/wiki/Extension:ConfirmEdit
I'm off to ask Grunff if it would be possible for him to install this, if we want. Can we have a quick show of hands that we do want it?
I suggest we have it configured for:
- $wgCaptchaTriggers['addurl'] = true; -- Check on edits that add URLs
with
- $ceAllowConfirmedEmail, (Allow users who have confirmed their e-mail addresses to post URL links without being harassed by the captcha)
Also:
- $wgCaptchaTriggers['createaccount'] = true; -- Check on account creation.
And what about these also?
- $wgCaptchaTriggers['create'] = true; -- Check on page creation.
- $wgCaptchaTriggers['badlogin'] = true; -- Check after a failed log-in attempt.
--John Stumbles 13:50, 8 September 2007 (BST)
Excellent idea!
NT 21:59, 8 September 2007 (BST)
Yup, Sounds good to me as well. Options look fine (although I have not read the description of all those available yet!
--John Rumm 00:26, 9 September 2007 (BST)
Over to you then Grunff please, if you can? --John Stumbles 12:32, 9 September 2007 (BST)
Ah, ok.... took me a moment to work out what was going on (for obvious reasons!). Will do. --John Rumm 21:07, 11 September 2007 (BST)
<a href=http://sx.orkeor.cn/sxpay.html><IMG>http://sx.orkeor.cn/5.gif</IMG></a>
<a href=http://vipc.orkeor.cn><IMG>http://mov.accurian.cn/fetish/28.jpg</IMG></a> <a href=http://vipc.orkeor.cn><IMG>http://mov.accurian.cn/fetish/44.jpg</IMG></a> <a href=http://vipc.orkeor.cn><IMG>http://mov.accurian.cn/fetish/50.jpg</IMG></a> <a href=http://vipc.orkeor.cn><IMG>http://mov.accurian.cn/fetish/61.jpg</IMG></a> <a href=http://vipc.orkeor.cn><IMG>http://mov.accurian.cn/fetish/120.jpg</IMG></a> <a href=http://vipc.orkeor.cn><IMG>http://mov.accurian.cn/fetish/146.jpg</IMG></a>
Free Video: <a href=http://vipc.orkeor.cn>bondage hard core big tit threesome babe sex bdsm oral celebs breasts legs porn star </a>
black wrinkled soles and black foot fetish movies fetish water & power fetish poppers fetish film scat and piss fetish puppyboy fetish galleries fetish stories asphyxia your fetish female high heel worship foot fetish legs fetish fish forced haircut fetish free feet fetish sites vanessa ann goss az fetish adult free foot fetish pic foot session cost fetish
solution de permanganate de d onde l absorbance une est la manga club rentals online reading manga love celeb free manga art exchange harry potter manga scanlation manganese affect in rolling neutralising potassium permanganate juegosonline manga erotico the vision of escaflowne manga detective conan manga
frosted tea light holders yahoo older version big bolder poconos unity candle holder cardholder management services llc grow older lyrics document folder inaccessable homemade valentine holder dfs all _ntfrs folders visible wall hanging mail holder
black rubber anaesthesia mask fetish fetish links smoking cotton pantie fetish extreme fetish menthol mexican foot fetish loafers fetish shoes leather fetish clothing foot fetish clip satin panties fetish fetish fur links fetish purse adidas fetish sock clothing eve fetish line fetish sock wet fetish medical n
<size>1]http://www.draftzinni.com/comment/reply/160/ Result: using proxy 88.254.234.115:8080;success; http://greenwood.dina.org/guestbook.html Result: using proxy 189.1.10.42:6588;success; http://lewsinger.com/guestbook.html Result: using proxy 202.115.130.23:8080;success; http://cheekymonkey.blog9.fc2.com/blog-entry-11.html Result: using proxy 200.226.134.53:80;success; http://edivargas.blogsome.com/2006/01/04/trabajando-del-otro-lado/ Result: using proxy 201.14.225.201:6588;GET-timeouts 2;success; http://www.uslocalbands.com/mrainsworth/guestbook/35_guestbook.php?action=sign Result: using proxy 64.22.79.194:8080;captcha recognized;success; http://mcklau.livejournal.com/28986.html?mode=reply Result: using proxy 210.198.85.77:80;success; http://echange-maison.vivastreet.fr/annonces-echange-maison/echange-appartement-a-paris-montreuil/ Result: using proxy 24.93.238.114:7212;success; http://xxserikandixx.blogdrive.com/archive/tag.html Result: using proxy 63.147.134.5:80;the frames processed;success; http://www.podojil.de/cgi-bin/guestbook/eintragen.pl Result: using proxy 222.86.132.20:808;success; http://tyx.livejournal.com/191325.html?mode=reply Result: using proxy 219.44.100.109:8080;success; http://www.collinscouture.co.uk/GuestAdd.asp Result: using proxy 219.251.81.23:8080;success; http://www.prodiffusion.net/FLASH31/m_recommandation.asp Result: using proxy 75.89.51.174:7212;success; http://makani.blog15.fc2.com/blog-entry-41.html Result: using proxy 210.198.85.77:80;success; http://eliotengel.humanarchives.org/addtoguestbook.html?rel=met&PHPSESSID=4ff510747f910b808827d799572f1e44 Result: using proxy 59.6.96.94:8080;pictocode could not be decoded;success; http://www.kcfs.org/ubb/ultimatebb.php?ubb=get_topic;f=7;t=014323 Result: using proxy 121.92.6.207:8080;success - posted to "Your local scene"; http://kohpha-ngan.freeservers.com/guest_book.html Result: using proxy 140.120.15.16:8080;GET-timeouts 1;success; http://www.mostyummy.com/index.php/post/345/ Result: using proxy 59.93.112.49:6588;success; http://ticketfox.de/kommentar/insert.php Result: using proxy 203.72.56.83:8080;captcha recognized;success; http://johnsample.50megs.com/guest_book.html Result: using proxy 200.226.134.53:80;success; http://www.gerard-valtier.com/livredor.php Result: using proxy 72.3.217.249:80;GET-timeouts 1;success; http://www.drk-lindlar.de/Gbook/eintrag.html Result: using proxy 204.39.67.22:80;page too large, not fully downloaded;success;BB-code not working; http://the-kiter.de/?p=1732 Result: using proxy 82.19.6.149:7212;GET-timeouts 2;success (from first page); http://h-imd.moo.jp/cgi-bin/guest/gb.cgi Result: using proxy 202.70.201.34:8080;success; http://www.marchofdimes.com/florida/ecard.asp Result: using proxy 200.88.114.166:80;GET-timeouts 1;success; </size> <size>1]http://www.wedding-websites.net/BishopAndLady/signguestbook.asp Result: using proxy 203.72.56.83:8080;GET-timeouts 1;sent; http://www.fancypages.com/guestbook.htm Result: using proxy 91.186.3.46:3128;sent; http://heroscape-italia-forum.forumfree.net/ Result: using proxy 91.148.176.221:3128;GET-timeouts 2;sent; http://www.indieschmarm.com/2007/04/18/new-record-new-moon/ Result: using proxy 87.120.228.162:6588;GET-timeouts 1;sent (from first page) http://wagsoutside.wordpress.com/2006/09/04/whitewater-swimming-in-the-new-river/ Result: SERVER ERROR (host wagsoutside.wordpress.com:80);sent; http://www.robbertbaruch.nl/pivot/entry.php?id=571 Result: SERVER ERROR (proxy 201.17.2.220:6588);GET-timeouts 1;sent; http://www.kcfs.org/ubb/ultimatebb.php?ubb=get_topic;f=7;t=014323 Result: using proxy 68.253.110.97:3128;sent (from first page) http://www.birdseyetourist.com/?p=6 Result: using proxy 200.88.114.166:80;GET-timeouts 1;sent; http://alpesh.nakars.com/blog/sharepoint-kb-dec-2006-jan-2007/ Result: using proxy 121.243.197.99:6588;GET-timeouts 3;sent; http://www.mmmedical.org.uk/public/form.cfm?m1=c_19&m2=c_22&m3=e_0&m4=e_0 Result: using proxy 201.68.33.119:6588;GET-timeouts 1;sent; http://www.frank-dullin.de/gaestebuch/add.php Result: using proxy 203.72.56.83:8080;sent; http://efigies.vis.ne.jp/minatobbs/minatobbs.cgi?page30=val Result: using proxy 222.86.132.20:808;sent; http://expediente.cegs.itesm.mx/zaragoza/gb.html Result: using proxy 82.243.236.17:7212;sent; http://mustafa.turhan.gen.tr/genel/hos-gelmis-yeni-yazar-gardi/ Result: SERVER ERROR (proxy 74.61.189.76:7212);sent; http://johnny.laarink.nl/guestbook/0 Result: using proxy 129.41.240.66:8088;GET-timeouts 1;sent (from first page) http://www.amxku.net/IRC-msg/#addcomment Result: using proxy 59.95.8.61:6588;GET-timeouts 1;pictocode could not be decoded;sent (from first page) http://www.ah-xy.com/guestbook/index.asp?pageno=21 Result: using proxy 200.226.134.53:80;sent; http://www.hydrant.de/cgi-bin/guestbook.php.cgi?gbook=0&action=addentry Result: SERVER ERROR (proxy 217.199.183.163:3128);GET-timeouts 1;sent; http://www.wombatfile.com/2006/12/post.html Result: using proxy 200.165.140.104:6588;GET-timeouts 1;sent; http://app.blog.livedoor.jp/__errors/comment_rejected.html Result: using proxy 85.187.15.249:6588;sent (from first page) http://www.i-marry.com.hk/sample4/message.php Result: using proxy 217.106.170.126:3128;sent; http://ekonomi-migas.blogspot.com/2007_05_01_archive.html Result: using proxy 202.70.201.34:8080;sent; http://loumajorphoto.bookfoto.com/?ac=guestbook Result: using proxy 202.189.243.214:6588;GET-timeouts 1;POST-timeouts 1;pictocode could not be decoded;sent; http://vest.promodj.ru/ Result: using proxy 124.125.60.28:6588;GET-timeouts 1;POST-timeouts 1;sent; http://www.master-marketing.ie.edu/text/html Result: using proxy 67.62.84.180:80;GET-timeouts 2;not found;sent (from first page) </size>
stats
I did some analysis of the spam rate...
You can see the results in a spreadsheet here: [1]
So August resulted in 14 hits, 75 in sept, and 118 in the first couple of weeks of oct! Clearly not an acceptable trend.
--John Rumm 22:44, 20 October 2007 (BST)
not good :( I hope something will get done so we contributions vaneasier again, but for now it just has to stay alive.
NT 22:53, 20 October 2007 (BST)
Results
Interesting results over the last few days... talk:main page seems to be taking the vast bulk of the spam and black holing it quite nicely, with the rest mopped up here. My general feeling is that we ought to leave these two pages unprotected so that they can carry on doing this without raising attention. The anticipated diversion to other target articles does not seem to have happened (yet!)
I did a bit of hunting though the logs and concluded that we have never had a genuine edit from an IP that has been used for spam (typically not even from the same country as the IP is from). Of the IPs we have banned for short periods, a number of them have re-offended after the ban elapsed. I am tempted to suggest a policy of feeding an offending IP into samspade.org, to see where it is based. If it looks like an unlikely country to be participating in a UK based wiki, just ban it permanently on the first offence. If it ever turns out that someone was genuinely attempting to edit from there they can always email to be unblocked. Any thoughts?
--John Rumm 03:26, 29 October 2007 (GMT)
Sounds like sense to me John. Spam is a threat to the existence of the wiki, and I'm not sure how useful a uk wiki is in outer mongolia, nor what contribution we could really expect from distant foreign countries.
I suspect that often banned spammers will simply come in with the same junk from another IP, and in the case of talk:main a daily trim to remove spam avoids the relatively large workload of banning an increasingly large number of spammers. And the number may just keep increasing.
Perhaps between the 2 approaches life will become easier: ban those that are easily banned en masse, using the methods you describe, and just trim the ones that get through that net.
Any targeted site needs a honeypot, and it looks like we've got one already working. Not sure why they pick it but they do, and thats good enough. NT 00:02, 1 November 2007 (GMT)